Technology card
ShippingShingled Magnetic Recording
SMR
How overlapping tracks change updates, and why the host interface matters as much as the recording label.
Glossary entry on hesela.dev · JSON record
Related
On this page6 sections
In one minute
SMR is an HDD recording layout that partially overlaps adjacent tracks to increase track density, requiring management of data affected by later writes.
An SMR write overlaps part of a previously written track, leaving a narrower readable portion. It does not narrow the write head itself. Rewriting that track can disturb later overlapping tracks, so data that must survive needs appropriate placement, buffering or rewriting. [7]
Physical bands bound this overlap dependency. Logical zones are the address ranges exposed by a host-visible zoned interface; they need not reveal exact physical band boundaries. Keeping those concepts separate avoids treating an interface map as a platter diagram. [3]
The three interface models assign different responsibilities. Drive-managed SMR accepts ordinary random writes and handles placement internally. Host-aware SMR accepts non-sequential writes in sequential-write-preferred zones. Host-managed SMR requires writes at the write pointer in sequential-write-required zones. Conventional zones are optional in the latter two models and permit random writes. [2]
One host update does not imply an immediate whole-band rewrite. Skylight tested two Seagate drive-managed SMR models with controlled I/O, adding head-motion observations for the 5 TB model. Their persistent disk caches staged updates before later cleaning into bands. This explains why short bursts and sustained writes can expose different costs; it is not a benchmark of every SMR drive. [8]
Historical dates also need a scope. On 9 September 2013, Seagate announced it had already shipped over one million SMR drives. That is evidence of a commercial shipment milestone, not the invention date or an independently verified first shipment. The earlier June 2013 USENIX article describes the physical data-management problem while host interfaces were still being defined. [9] [7]
Compared to neighbors
CMR avoids intentional shingled overlap. SMR changes track layout, while drive-managed, host-aware and host-managed describe the host contract. Random-write acceptance alone is not evidence that a drive uses CMR.
Uncertainty notes
- Source review only: no new hardware experiment, failure-rate estimate or class-wide performance guarantee.
- The SNIA 2014 tutorial supports mechanism distinctions; draft-era command details are not presented as current requirements.
- The 2013 shipment count is attributed to Seagate, not independently reproduced.
- The workload-qualification caution is an engineering inference from the separation of recording layout, interface and implementation.
Sources
- 01Seagate — CMR and SMR hard drive list · accessed 2026-10-06
- 02Zoned Storage — Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) introduction · accessed 2026-11-05
- 03Mary Dunn and Timothy Feldman: Shingled Magnetic Recording - Models, Standardization, and Applications, SNIA 2014, slides 12-14 and 16-20 · accessed 2026-11-05
- 04Western Digital — Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) HDD technology white paper · accessed 2026-10-06
- 05Western Digital — WD Red SMR vs CMR NAS drive information · accessed 2026-10-06
- 06Seagate Surveillance HDD v2 manual — SMR zones and ZAC commands · accessed 2026-10-06
- 07Tim Feldman and Garth Gibson: Shingled Magnetic Recording - Areal Density Increase Requires New Data Management, USENIX ;login: June 2013, pp. 22-24 · accessed 2026-11-05
- 08Abutalib Aghayev and Peter Desnoyers: Skylight - A Window on Shingled Disk Operation, FAST 2015, section 2, Figure 2 and sections 4.3-4.5; sections 3.2, 4.2 and Table 3 · accessed 2026-11-05
- 09Seagate: shipment milestone announcement, 9 September 2013 · accessed 2026-11-05